NASCAR Roundtable: Does the punishment fit the crime?

The NASCAR team discusses penalties handed out by NASCAR this weekend to Johnny Sauter and Ross Chastain, as well as who the favorites are to win in Sonoma.

NASCAR Roundtable: Does the punishment fit the crime?
 Johnny Sauter, ThorSport Racing, Ford F-150 Tenda Products
Johnny Sauter, ThorSport Racing, Ford F-150 and Joe Shear Jr
Johnny Sauter, ThorSport Racing, Ford F-150
 Johnny Sauter, ThorSport Racing, Ford F-150 Tenda Heal
 Austin Hill, Hattori Racing Enterprises, Toyota Tundra ARCO National Construction
Race Winner Ross Chastain, Niece Motorsports, Chevrolet Silverado TruNorth/Paul Jr. Designs
 Ross Chastain, Niece Motorsports, Chevrolet Silverado TruNorth/Paul Jr. Designs checkered flag
\ Ross Chastain, Niece Motorsports, Chevrolet Silverado TruNorth/Paul Jr. Designs,  Austin Wayne Self, AM Racing, Chevrolet Silverado GO TEXAN/ ICEBOX Helmet Coolers and  Raphael Lessard, DGR-Crosley, Toyota Tundra RESEAU Dynamique.com / FRL Express INC.
Race Winner Ross Chastain, Niece Motorsports, Chevrolet Silverado TruNorth/Paul Jr. Designs
Kyle Busch, Joe Gibbs Racing Toyota
Race winner Kyle Busch, Joe Gibbs Racing
Martin Truex Jr., Furniture Row Racing, Toyota Camry 5-hour ENERGY/Bass Pro Shops
Martin Truex Jr., Furniture Row Racing, Toyota Camry 5-hour ENERGY/Bass Pro Shops in victory lane
Polesitter Will Rodgers
Will Rodgers
Listen to this article

Do you think Johnny Sauter's punishment of a one-race suspension by NASCAR fits the offense from Sunday at Iowa Speedway?

Jim Utter: I think it was an appropriate punishment. NASCAR has never tolerated retaliation while the race is under caution - for safety concerns above all else I would suspect. It's one thing to beat and bang with an opponent racing for position. It's quite another to take your wrecked race truck, run down someone under caution and then wreck them. Sauter is lucky he didn't lose more than one race.

Nick DeGroot: Let me preface this by saying that I get Sauter's frustrations. Both at Texas and Iowa his race ended after contact with Austin Hill, but wrecking someone under caution is big no. The one-race suspension is deserved and it doesn't change his eligibility for the playoffs, so it's more a timeout than anything else.

Tim Southers: I think the punishment was appropriate and in line with previous incidents where a driver uses their vehicle for retaliation under caution. I’m a little surprised they didn’t make the penalty a little more severe. I’m willing to bet if he would have collected any more trucks in his incident on the track with Austin Hill there might have been a bigger hammer dropped on the veteran.

Ross Chastain had his win taken away after his truck failed post-race inspection at Iowa Speedway. Do you think this will keep him from qualifying for the playoffs?

Jim: Getting into the Top 20 in points in Trucks wasn't going to be terribly difficult for Chastain to begin with but earning the victory needed to get in was going to be the most difficult. I still think Chastain can get in the Top 20 in points, but you never know when the opportunity for a win will present itself. So far, though, Chastain has managed to overcome every obstacle put in his racing path of late.

Nick: Excluding the disqualification, Ross has finished inside the top-ten in every single race this year. They are fully capable of winning again and probably will. Cracking the Top 20 in points will be the easy part, but overcoming this major setback and winning again will be the true test of this team. And if you want to know what I think, I believe they'll get it done.

Tim: I tend to agree with Jim that Chastain is talented enough and his team has good enough equipment to make it into the top 20 in the truck standings that is struggling to field trucks for the entire season back to 20th-place. I think his best shot for a win could actually come this weekend in St. Louis.

Kyle Busch (2008 & 2015) and Martin Truex Jr. (2013 & 2018) lead all active drivers with a pair of wins at Sonoma Raceway? Do you consider them the two favorites to win this Sunday?

Jim: I think they will definitely be in the mix but I also expect Brad Keselowski and Kevin Harvick to be among the drivers in contention for the victory. The big question mark will be how the addition of "The Carousel" will change race strategy and whether it will favor some drivers over others.

Nick: Absolutely, but don't discount Kevin Harvick. He was right with Truex last year and won the year prior in 2017. Harvick is facing a surprising winless streak so the motivation is there, and we all know he has the talent to capture the checkered flag.

Tim: I think anyone would have to consider those two drivers for the win, however this will be a different race this year. The “Carousel” returns to the layout of the road course so we’ll see if that makes a big difference. In addition to Busch and Truex, I think you would also need to include Denny Hamlin and Kevin Harvick in that mix. Harvick is still looking for his first win of the season and Hamlin has been fast there before.

The K&N Pro Series West race will be held on Saturday ahead of the Cup race on Sunday at Sonoma Raceway. Hailie Deegan has already won twice this season ... do you think she can add a road course win to her resume this weekend?

Jim: I think Deegan will have to wait another day. Saturday's race is stacked with three full-time Cup Series drivers, two full-time Xfinity Series drivers and a number of others with far more road course experience than Deegan, including last year's winner, Will Rodgers. I would think Deegan would be satisfied with a solid finish that keeps her in contention for the K&N Pro Series West title.

Nick: I am going to say no, but I'd say that for most K&N regulars. This is going to be a stacked field with several Cup and Xfinity drivers among the entrants. I'd go with one of them to win the race.

Tim: I think she is plenty talented - and aggressive enough - to win on the challenging layout at Sonoma Raceway, but I also think it will not come this weekend. The announcement of several NASCAR national series drivers entered in the race I think will make that hill to high to climb for this weekend’s race. In addition to Austin Dillon, Noah Gragson, Cole Custer and others in the race, former event winner Will Rodgers has already proven he can get in done at Sonoma Raceway and he is actually my favorite to win again.

From the editor, also read:

shares
comments
NASCAR Cup teams honoring Darrell Waltrip's 'Last Call'
Previous article

NASCAR Cup teams honoring Darrell Waltrip's 'Last Call'

Next article

2019 Sonoma/Gateway NASCAR weekend schedules

2019 Sonoma/Gateway NASCAR weekend schedules
The ex-F1 driver taking on NASCAR with a new team Prime

The ex-F1 driver taking on NASCAR with a new team

Saddled with uncompetitive Minardi machinery, Tarso Marques didn't manage to score points in his three partial seasons of Formula 1. But now the Brazilian has the chance to show what he can do in NASCAR, and explains the story of his comeback with new Cup Series entrant Team Stange

NASCAR Cup
Apr 13, 2022
The early benefits and challenges of NASCAR's Next Gen car Prime

The early benefits and challenges of NASCAR's Next Gen car

NASCAR’s new stock car generation is encouraging an influx of fresh blood into its top tier. But there are concerns that parts are in short supply as the entire paddock tries to build up stocks at the same time

NASCAR Cup
Feb 22, 2022
How Penske's rookie sensation opened NASCAR's new era in style Prime

How Penske's rookie sensation opened NASCAR's new era in style

After holding his nerve and hip-checking his teammate on the run to the line, Austin Cindric made a perfect start to life as a full-timer in the NASCAR Cup Series by winning the Daytona 500. Here's how the Penske Ford man emerged first across the line in the first points-scoring race for the much-anticipated Next Generation cars

NASCAR Cup
Feb 21, 2022
Six key themes to follow in the 2022 NASCAR Cup season Prime

Six key themes to follow in the 2022 NASCAR Cup season

There are plenty of uncertainties ahead of the 2022 NASCAR Cup season as an all-new fleet of cars take to the track for the first time. Ahead of this weekend's Daytona 500, our experts explain what you need to know

NASCAR Cup
Feb 17, 2022
How NASCAR had to learn a harsh lesson ahead of Next Gen arrival Prime

How NASCAR had to learn a harsh lesson ahead of Next Gen arrival

The NASCAR Cup kicks off with the Daytona 500 this weekend, but a major engine overhaul and a subsequent mountain of work has been required to be ready for the arrival of the Next Gen cars.

NASCAR Cup
Feb 16, 2022
How Larson took the long way round to NASCAR Cup glory Prime

How Larson took the long way round to NASCAR Cup glory

From villain to hero, Kyle Larson had to reach his lifelong goal the hard way and go through a very public shaming after a ban for using a racial slur, but his talents shone long before his name grabbed the headlines...

NASCAR Cup
Nov 10, 2021
How NASCAR is gearing up for its "biggest change" in 2022 Prime

How NASCAR is gearing up for its "biggest change" in 2022

It’s not just Formula 1 that’s set for upheaval in 2022, as the NASCAR Cup series adopts its Next Gen cars that will cast any in-built advantages aside and require teams to adopt a totally new way of operating. Far more than just a change of machinery, the new cars amount to a shift in NASCAR's core philosophy

NASCAR Cup
Oct 12, 2021
Why Bubba Wallace’s Talladega win is such a big moment for NASCAR Prime

Why Bubba Wallace’s Talladega win is such a big moment for NASCAR

Bubba Wallace claimed his maiden NASCAR Cup Series at Talladega on Monday to become the first Black victor in the category since Wendell Scott in 1963. Both Wallace and Scott had faced obstacles and racism in their paths to their breakthrough wins, and NASCAR is trying to put it right with its range of diversity programmes

NASCAR Cup
Oct 5, 2021