Commentary

IndyCar Indy 500

Opinion: Don’t dilute the challenge of Indy

It’s a sensational situation: Within 24 hours, two IndyCars equipped with Chevrolet aero kits took flight at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway in the short chute exiting the first turn of the legendary 2.5-mile oval.

Anne Proffit

Edited: May 15, 2015, 3:45 PM

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

Helio Castroneves flips

Debris after Josef Newgarden's crash

Debris after Josef Newgarden's crash

Safety crew members check the damage after Josef Newgarden's crash

Josef Newgarden, CFH Racing Chevrolet

Townsend Bell, Dreyer and Reinbold Racing Chevrolet's wicker

Helio Castroneves, Team Penske Chevrolet

Josef Newgarden flip damage

Pippa Mann, Dale Coyne Racing Honda in huge crash

Pippa Mann, Dale Coyne Racing Honda in huge crash

Pippa Mann, Dale Coyne Racing Honda in huge crash

Practice for the 99th Indianapolis 500 has had more big accidents from Monday through Thursday than I can remember for all of last year’s meeting.

This is the first year of use for Chevrolet and Honda aero kits, and it’s bound to have its ramifications. The aero kits change how cars can work around one another and how they react to the oval track and its considerable, hour-by-hour climate changes.

You can’t simulate Indianapolis in the vacuum of CFD (computational fluid dynamics) or through windtunnel or other simulations. It just can’t be done.

As we’ve seen, with Helio Castroneves’ flying escapade in the first turn on Wednesday and yesterday, when Barber winner Josef Newgarden crashed in nearly the same place, simulations of this track just don’t translate.

Chevy’s quick fix

After Castroneves’ flight on Wednesday afternoon, Chevrolet teams were told to remove the center wicker bill that runs the length of each car’s nose. This was after CFD studies, and Chevrolet felt the wicker might have been a partial contributor to the liftoff.

But then Newgarden’s crash happened too, from which he appeared to emerge shaken but otherwise altogether, so the IndyCar garage is exploding with ways to fix – or demands to fix – whatever is causing these accidents to occur in this manner.

IndyCar already reduced the size of its spec floor this year, and implemented large holes to help reduce the chances of takeoff in a high-speed spinning situation. But when we experiment with aerodynamics in a real-world situation, as we have at this racetrack, we are bound to have ramifications we cannot explain in scientific fashion because, hey, we haven’t done this before.

We also have the human element involved, as drivers tend to react to situations in different manners. And whether either of these incidents was due to driver error, I don’t know.

In my opinion, the third major accident where Pippa Mann failed to recognize a slowing car in front of her and had to check up, sending her car on a wild ride and damaging the Dallara tub to the point of needing an Aerodine repair, certainly qualifies as such. The other two are still up to conjecture.

No knee-jerk reactions

In any case, I do believe it is in IndyCar’s best interest not to suppose the sky is falling and to change its rules to suit these particular incidents. Yes, do due diligence on cause, effect – as you should – but don’t say “no this, no that, let’s change everything” on the morrow before the qualifying weekend.

The 99th Indianapolis 500 is too important a race to dilute. It has been the thrill of choice for drivers since 1911 and they all know the consequences they face when they get behind the wheel.

Yes, let’s look to improve safety but, please, no knee-jerk reactions.

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Read also :

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Previous article Newgarden escapes airborne crash uninjured

Next article Legge to drive for all-women team in 2016 Indy 500

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

More from

Anne Proffit



NHRA update: Virginia joins schedule, top teams make lineup changes

NHRA

NHRA Jan 30, 2018

NHRA update: Virginia joins schedule, top teams make lineup changes



Englishtown shuts down drag racing operations with immediate effect

NHRA

NHRA Jan 17, 2018

Englishtown shuts down drag racing operations with immediate effect



John Force gains honorary doctorate from UNOH

NHRA

NHRA Jan 10, 2018

John Force gains honorary doctorate from UNOH

More from

Helio Castroneves



IndyCar 2026 season review: Meyer Shank Racing

IndyCar

IndyCar 3 d

IndyCar 2026 season review: Meyer Shank Racing



Team Penske and Chevrolet announce multi-year extension of IndyCar partnership

IndyCar

IndyCar 1 mo

Team Penske and Chevrolet announce multi-year extension of IndyCar partnership



Where will Kevin Magnussen rank among the Project 91 NASCAR drivers?

NASCAR Cup

NASCAR Cup

San Diego

5 mo

Where will Kevin Magnussen rank among the Project 91 NASCAR drivers?

More from

Team Penske



Josef Newgarden extends tenure with Team Penske in multi-year deal

IndyCar

IndyCar 1 d

Josef Newgarden extends tenure with Team Penske in multi-year deal



IndyCar 2026 season review: Team Penske

IndyCar

IndyCar 2 d

IndyCar 2026 season review: Team Penske



You Ask The Questions: David Malukas

IndyCar

You Ask The Questions: David Malukas

Latest news



"It was scary at 100km/h" - F1 drivers shocked by Las Vegas 'ice rink'

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

5 min

"It was scary at 100km/h" - F1 drivers shocked by Las Vegas 'ice rink'



Marc Marquez nervous about expected MotoGP coronation: "I see risks everywhere"

MotoGP

MGP MotoGP

Portuguese GP

37 min

Marc Marquez nervous about expected MotoGP coronation: "I see risks everywhere"



George Russell impressed by "exceptionally fast" McLaren as rain delays Lando Norris' floor test

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

42 min

George Russell impressed by "exceptionally fast" McLaren as rain delays Lando Norris' floor test



Pirelli reintroduces stint limit for F1 Qatar GP

Formula 1

F1 Formula 1

Qatar GP

1 h

Pirelli reintroduces stint limit for F1 Qatar GP

Feature

Discover prime content



How Spanish engineering and Alex Palou brought IndyCar to Barcelona

Feature

IndyCar

Feature

IndyCar 21 d

By Joey Barnes

How Spanish engineering and Alex Palou brought IndyCar to Barcelona



Inside AJ Foyt Racing’s transition: Hauger’s arrival, Ferrucci’s future, and the Pierson waiting game

Feature

IndyCar

Feature

IndyCar 2 mo

By Joey Barnes

Inside AJ Foyt Racing’s transition: Hauger’s arrival, Ferrucci’s future, and the Pierson waiting game



You Ask The Questions: David Malukas

IndyCar

By Joey Barnes

You Ask The Questions: David Malukas



Top 10 Ganassi IndyCar drivers of all time

IndyCar

By John Oreovicz

Top 10 Ganassi IndyCar drivers of all time

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts

Subscribe