IndyCar
R
Birmingham
16 Apr
Next event in
39 days
23 Apr
Next event in
46 days
R
Texas
30 Apr
Next event in
53 days
R
Grand Prix of Indianapolis Race 1
14 May
Next event in
67 days
28 May
Next event in
81 days
R
Detroit
11 Jun
Next event in
95 days
R
Road America
18 Jun
Next event in
102 days
R
Mid-Ohio
02 Jul
Next event in
116 days
R
Toronto
09 Jul
Next event in
123 days
06 Aug
Next event in
151 days
R
Grand Prix of Indianapolis Race 2
13 Aug
Next event in
158 days
R
Gateway
20 Aug
Next event in
165 days
R
Portland
10 Sep
Next event in
186 days
R
Laguna Seca
17 Sep
Next event in
193 days
R
Long Beach
24 Sep
Next event in
200 days

IRL: CHAMPCAR/CART: Indy 500 final decision

George upholds Castroneves' Indianapolis 500 victory. INDIANAPOLIS, Wednesday, July 3, 2002 -- Tony George, president and CEO of the Indy Racing League, today upheld the determination that Helio Castroneves won the 2002 Indianapolis 500-Mile Race ...

IRL: CHAMPCAR/CART: Indy 500 final decision

George upholds Castroneves' Indianapolis 500 victory.

INDIANAPOLIS, Wednesday, July 3, 2002 -- Tony George, president and CEO of the Indy Racing League, today upheld the determination that Helio Castroneves won the 2002 Indianapolis 500-Mile Race and denied the final appeal by Team Green, Inc.

In an 11-page decision released today to the public, George determined that the decision by Indy Racing League officials as to the placement of the race cars at the commencement of the yellow caution period immediately after an accident on Lap 199 "is a judgment call and is not protestable nor appealable under the Rule Book."

George also concluded that League officials were correct in determining that Castroneves' No. 3 car was ahead of Paul Tracy's No. 26 car on Lap 199 when the yellow caution period commenced, and that ample evidence supports that determination.

Team Green, owner of Tracy's car, protested the finish of the race to Indy Racing League Vice President of Operations Brian Barnhart, who denied the protest. Team Green then filed an appeal of that decision. Under League rules, George chose to personally handle the final appeal by conducting an all-day hearing June 17. Representatives of Team Green and Penske Racing appeared at the hearing, along with Indy Racing League officials.

"The fact that the race ended under yellow was not the fault of anyone involved in this proceeding," George said. "How it is handled, however, does reflect directly on the participants. In my opinion, this proceeding has highlighted the quality and integrity of the work done by Brian Barnhart and his staff, both during and after the race, and has also shown the quality and integrity of the personnel employed by Team Green and Penske Racing."

Under Rule 11.2 of the 2002 Indy Racing League rules, the decision whether a car passed another car during a yellow caution period or any matter which involves the exercise of judgment by the officials during an event "may not be protested or appealed and the decision of the officials is final and binding."

"To second-guess the officials either for calling a yellow caution or for their placement of the order of the cars is not allowed under the rules and for good reason," George said. "Judgment calls must be final, and that is the only way to conduct a motorsports race."

The information presented to George showed that Castroneves was leading Tracy at the time Race Control called the yellow caution period by radio; at the time the red flag with yellow cross (pits closed) was displayed; at the time the yellow dashboard light system was activated; at the last scoring time line before the yellow caution period commenced; and at the time the yellow dashboard light radio on car No. 3 received the yellow light signal.

George noted that, in "real time racing," a yellow caution period begins when Race Control calls it on the radio, a consistent practice since the Indy Racing League started.

"There is simply no alternative for the IRL officials when running a race," George said. "There is no instant replay in the Indy Racing League Rule Book. The drivers are instructed to react to the first notice they receive of a yellow caution condition, whether a yellow flag, a yellow track light, a yellow dashboard light or Race Control radio instruction.

"The reason for immediate reaction to a yellow caution is for the safety of the drivers and safety personnel since it signifies an unsafe track condition," George said. "We have several overlapping modes of communication as backup to each other since any can fail or be delayed. These modes of communication are not integrated to initiate at the exact same point in time because they can't be, and attempting to synchronize them exactly would delay the warning system and defeat the objective of maximizing safety."

Team Green contended that Tracy passed Castroneves before the track light turned from green to yellow. It was the finding of George that the track light was one of several systems in place and that there was clear evidence that other caution notices had been given before any pass was made.

Penske Racing contended that Castroneves was ahead when the caution was called and that Castroneves immediately slowed. The decision noted that Castroneves had more than a gallon of fuel remaining after having completed the 200 laps of the race plus a victory lap.

George noted that there were five yellow cautions called during this year's Indianapolis 500, all for the safety of the drivers.

"Officials must use their judgment in making these calls," George said. "The IRL officials do not have the benefit of instant replay, telemetry data or any other device to make their judgment. Rather, when they call a yellow caution period on Race Control radio, they immediately determine the placement of all of the cars from visual observation and from observation of television monitors in Race Control.

"That is precisely why the Rule Book states that the decision whether a car was improperly passed during a yellow caution period may not be protested or appealed," George said. "This is a determination Barnhart must make at the commencement of every yellow caution period during every race for every car on the race track, whether the caution period commences on the first lap, the last lap or any lap in between."

The whole process, George said, has increased his respect for both Team Green and Penske Racing.

"I wish that I could make them both happy with my decision, but unfortunately that can't be the case," George said.

-ims-

Indy Racing League complete official release, part I

shares
comments
CHAMPCAR/CART: Cristiano da Matta press conference, part I

Previous article

CHAMPCAR/CART: Cristiano da Matta press conference, part I

Next article

CHAMPCAR/CART: Pook's take on present and future

CHAMPCAR/CART: Pook's take on present and future
Load comments

About this article

Series IndyCar
Drivers Paul Tracy , Tony George , Brian Barnhart
Teams Team Penske
Is Arrow McLaren SP ready for IndyCar’s title fight? Prime

Is Arrow McLaren SP ready for IndyCar’s title fight?

With Patricio O'Ward and Felix Rosenqvist leading its line-up, 2021 could be the year Arrow McLaren SP-Chevrolet joins the IndyCar elite, writes David Malsher-Lopez.

IndyCar
Feb 21, 2021
Dale Coyne picks the Top 10 drivers in his giant-slaying team Prime

Dale Coyne picks the Top 10 drivers in his giant-slaying team

Over 37 seasons, Dale Coyne has run no fewer than 80 Indy car drivers – including himself! Ahead of his first season running Romain Grosjean, we asked Coyne to pick the best 10 drivers ever to compete for him. By David Malsher-Lopez.

IndyCar
Feb 10, 2021
Why enigmatic Marco Andretti will be missed Prime

Why enigmatic Marco Andretti will be missed

Last Friday, Marco Andretti announced he is withdrawing from fulltime IndyCar racing. David Malsher-Lopez explains how this third-gen racer was a puzzle in the car, but a straight shooter off-track.

IndyCar
Jan 19, 2021
Why Roger Penske is an American motorsport icon Prime

Why Roger Penske is an American motorsport icon

In this exclusive one-on-one interview, Roger Penske reveals the inner drive that has made him not only a hugely successful team owner and businessman but also the owner of Indianapolis Motor Speedway and IndyCar. He spoke to David Malsher-Lopez.

IndyCar
Dec 28, 2020
Is the mighty McLaren M16 the greatest ever Indy car? Prime

Is the mighty McLaren M16 the greatest ever Indy car?

When founder Bruce McLaren died in June 1970, his team could have folded. Instead, his loyal band rallied to produce a string of winners - including an Indy car game-changer that won three Indy 500s in six years.

IndyCar
Dec 23, 2020
How Newgarden delivered his best season, yet still lost Prime

How Newgarden delivered his best season, yet still lost

Josef Newgarden was our pick as top IndyCar driver of 2020 but his finest season-long run of performances failed to yield the championship. David Malsher-Lopez explains why.

IndyCar
Dec 18, 2020
2020 IndyCar Review and Top 10 drivers of the year Prime

2020 IndyCar Review and Top 10 drivers of the year

David Malsher-Lopez explains how the 2020 NTT IndyCar Series was unlike any other, and why it featured familiar and unfamiliar faces competing for glory.

IndyCar
Nov 27, 2020
How Dixon won his sixth IndyCar title, in his own words Prime

How Dixon won his sixth IndyCar title, in his own words

Chip Ganassi Racing’s newly crowned six-time IndyCar champion Scott Dixon takes us round by round through his remarkable season. David Malsher-Lopez listens.

IndyCar
Nov 4, 2020