FIA explains why Ferrari winglet has been banned

The FIA has explained why Ferrari's "liberal" and "tenuous" interpretation of the Formula 1 rules around mounting mirrors on the halo has been banned after just one race.

FIA explains why Ferrari winglet has been banned

Ferrari became the first team to roll out mirrors attached to the cockpit protection device at the Spanish Grand Prix, placing a winglet above the housing supporting it.

It attracted attention from several teams, with Force India technical director Andrew Green admitting he thought that design was not allowed, but it was passed legal for the weekend.

However, it emerged that the FIA had sought to clarify that Ferrari would need to alter the device for the next race in Monaco, and FIA race director Charlie Whiting has now explained why.

"It's a liberal interpretation of the word 'mounting' because that's how they become legal," he said. "The interpretation hinges on whether we think that's a mounting or not. We somehow think not.

"They think it contributes to the rigidity of the mirror. I doubt they would be there if there wasn't a measurable aero advantage, but these days that doesn't have to be big.

"We sent a technical directive a few weeks ago in response to a number of questions from other teams about the principle of mounting a mirror on the halo was acceptable.

"We answered yes, and gave a few stipulations, one that it has to be a mounting. It's just a matter of interpretation and such a tenuous interpretation is not something we're happy with."

Ferrari SF71H mirror detail, Spanish GP
Ferrari SF71H mirror detail, Spanish GP

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

Whiting said that if the design appears in Monaco "we're probably going to see the stewards about it".

Asked if the device was effectively banned, despite not breaching a specific regulation, he replied: "Yes, you could say that."

Ferrari was allowed to continue running the mirrors in Spain because it is FIA precedent to be "reasonable" when a matter is not a clear rule break and down to a difference in interpretation.

However, Ferrari driver Sebastian Vettel does not understand why it is being banned at all.

He said it was no different to teams using aerodynamic pieces when the mirror is mounted elsewhere on the car and suggested "everybody needs to change part of their mirrors" as well.

"For us it is straightforward, we see better," he said. "That was the point of moving them.

"We asked already in the beginning of the year during the first seat-fit with the halo if we can move them on the halo. The winglet, I think we're doing the same as everybody else with their mirrors."

Expert view, by Gary Anderson

Ferrari has opened a can of worms by becoming the first team to move its rear-view mirror mountings from the chassis to the halo.

Clearly, its objective was to get a higher-mounted turning vane to help pull more mass airflow down into the top opening of the sidepods.

This upper turning vane is quite a distance from that opening, but getting the flow to turn in that direction means that the low pressure behind the internal radiator will pull airflow into the inlet duct, and hence through the radiator.

The mirror itself is not a million miles away from the original mounting position, so it clearly hasn't been done with rear vision as the prime motivation despite Sebastian Vettel saying it has made a difference.

Mounting it on a single vane, with the secondary supposed 'support' also coming off that vane effectively reveals Ferrari's reasoning.

My big question is why was Ferrari allowed to run it at all? The original mirrors were still there, as we saw the car with both mirrors attached on Friday.

Well done to the FIA for saying it must change it for Monaco and not letting it get out of hand. But, in reality, it should have told them on Thursday before this event started that the mirrors needed to be changed for Barcelona.

Additional reporting by Roberto Chinchero

Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF71H with mirror on halo
Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF71H with mirror on halo

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Sutton Images

shares
comments
Pirelli: F1 risked Spanish GP "lottery" with unaltered tyres

Previous article

Pirelli: F1 risked Spanish GP "lottery" with unaltered tyres

Next article

Sebastian Vettel defends Ferrari's pit decision in Spanish F1 GP, criticises VSC system

Sebastian Vettel defends Ferrari's pit decision in Spanish F1 GP, criticises VSC system
Load comments
Why the end is nigh for F1’s most dependable design tool Prime

Why the end is nigh for F1’s most dependable design tool

Wind tunnel work forms the bedrock of aerodynamic development in Formula 1. But as Pat Symonds explains, advances in virtual research are signalling the end of these expensive and complicated relics.

Formula 1
Jun 13, 2021
Why Mosley’s legacy amounts to far more than tabloid rumour Prime

Why Mosley’s legacy amounts to far more than tabloid rumour

The newspapers, naturally, lingered over Max Mosley’s tainted family history and niche sexual practices. But this is to trivialise the legacy of a big beast of motor racing politics. Stuart Codling weighs the life of a man whose work for safety on both road and track has saved hundreds of thousands of lives, but whose penchant for cruelty remains problematic and polarising.

Formula 1
Jun 12, 2021
Why pragmatic Perez isn't fazed by no-nonsense Red Bull F1 culture Prime

Why pragmatic Perez isn't fazed by no-nonsense Red Bull F1 culture

Sergio Perez has spent most of his career labouring in Formula 1’s midfield, wondering whether he’d ever get another shot at the big time. Red Bull has handed him that chance and, although life at the top is tough, the Baku winner is doing all the right things to get on terms with Max Verstappen, says BEN ANDERSON

Formula 1
Jun 11, 2021
What the data tells us about the F1 2021 title fight Prime

What the data tells us about the F1 2021 title fight

Formula 1 has been tracking car performance using timing loops mounted every 200m around each circuit – to the extent that it was able to anticipate Ferrari’s 'surprise’ pole in Monaco. PAT SYMONDS explains what this means for this season and beyond

Formula 1
Jun 10, 2021
The weighty issue F1 needs to find a balance with Prime

The weighty issue F1 needs to find a balance with

OPINION: After consecutive street races with contrasting highlights, one theme stood out which has become a prevalent issue with modern Formula 1 cars. But is there a way to solve it or, at least, reach a happy middle ground to help all parties?

Formula 1
Jun 10, 2021
The changes behind a 'feel-good' F1 result in Baku Prime

The changes behind a 'feel-good' F1 result in Baku

OPINION: The Azerbaijan Grand Prix had elements that make Formula 1 really exciting – unpredictability and shock results. This resulted in heartbreak for several of the championship’s regular contenders and joy for others who rarely reach the ultimate limelight. And one of those on the Baku podium is riding a wave of form he’s keen to continue

Formula 1
Jun 9, 2021
The human cost to replacing Formula 1's cancelled rounds Prime

The human cost to replacing Formula 1's cancelled rounds

OPINION: With the global pandemic still lingering, Singapore's grand prix has been cancelled for 2021, with more looking likely to follow. Although Formula 1 has TV deals and profits to chase, retaining a 23-race calendar could be most harmful to those who sacrifice the most for the championship.

Formula 1
Jun 8, 2021
Azerbaijan Grand Prix Driver Ratings Prime

Azerbaijan Grand Prix Driver Ratings

An eventful weekend in Baku full of incident and drama lent the race result an unusual feel, as three drivers scored their first podiums of the year. But it wasn't the eventual race winner who scored top marks in our driver ratings

Formula 1
Jun 7, 2021