Analysis

Formula 1

Rules are rules for a reason - Engine unfreeze tug of war continues

Taking a deeper look at the engine unfreeze debate.

Kate Walker

Kate Walker

Edited: Oct 14, 2014, 5:59 PM

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Add as a preferred source

Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director and Christian Horner, Red Bull Racing Team Principal in the FIA Press Conference

Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director (Right)

Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director

Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director

The FIA Press Conference, McLaren Racing Director; Monisha Kaltenborn, Sauber Team Principal; Franz Tost, Scuderia Toro Rosso Team Principal; Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director; Christian Horner, Red Bull Racing Team Principal;

Kamui Kobayashi, Caterham CT05 leads Max Chilton, Marussia F1 Team MR03 and Jules Bianchi, Marussia F1 Team MR03 on the grid

Narain Karthikeyan, HRT Formula One Team HRT leads team mate Pedro De La Rosa, HRT Formula 1 Team

Kamui Kobayashi, Caterham CT05

Romain Grosjean, Lotus F1 E22 leads Adrian Sutil, Sauber C33

Pastor Maldonado, Lotus F1 E21 is launched into the air after colliding with Esteban Gutierrez, Sauber C33

(L to R): Andrei Cheglakov, Marussia Team Owner on the grid with Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director and Mika Hakkinen (FIN)

Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director and his wife Susie Wolff, Williams FW35 Development Driver

Mercedes logos

Ferrari logo

Renault logo on the Red Bull Racing RB10 engine cover

(L to R): Niki Lauda, Mercedes Non-Executive Chairman with Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director and Paddy Lowe, Mercedes AMG F1 Executive Director

Over the course of the Russian Grand Prix weekend, talk of changing the F1 rulebook to allow for additional in-season development on the hybrid power units gathered pace, with Red Bull team principal Christian Horner revealing at the Friday press conference that the concept had been discussed and agreed on by the F1 Strategy Group before Mercedes boss Toto Wolff changed his mind.

Mercedes is standing in the way, as they should be

It should come as no surprise that Renault Sport F1, Ferrari, and their customers all support the idea of a late rule change, as the two OEMs have not been able to match the might of the Mercedes engine facility at Brixworth when it comes to the power and efficiency of the new units. To the outside world, changing the rules to accommodate sub-par performance is both laughable and inconsistent with the concept of a rulebook.

But one of F1’s greatest weaknesses has long been its inability to be consistent. While inconsistency on track can make for exciting racing, inconsistency in the rulebook just makes a mess.

It hasn't been easy for young F1 teams

In 2009 the FIA welcomed four new teams to the sport, all of them attracted in part by a promised budget cap that would level the playing field and make it theoretically possible for the incomers to compete with the big boys once they’d adjusted to the sport.

Of those four new teams, USF1 failed to make the grid at all, while HRT (originally Campos Meta) lasted three short years, and the two left standing - currently racing as Caterham and Marussia - have both seen changes of ownership and are fighting to survive. As for fighting with the big boys? Two points have been scored between the four entrants in five seasons, and both of those came about at this year’s Monaco Grand Prix.

Sauber and Lotus also teetering on the edge

F1’s history has long been littered with teams that failed to make the grade for a variety of reasons, and the struggles faced by Caterham and Marussia are not unique to those incomers, with the longer-pedigreed Sauber and Lotus also on the brink of financial ruin. But had the promised budget cap not disappeared before either team lined up at the 2010 season-opener in Bahrain it is fair to say that both outfits would have had a greater chance at competitiveness and increased odds of long-term survival.

Which is why news that even the FIA is giving its support to the notion of an engine unfreeze is surprising. Shocking, even. For unless it is mandated that any additional costs arising from in-season power unit development are swallowed entirely by the engine manufacturer, changing the engine regulations and increasing the bills payable will be the final nail in the coffin for teams fighting to survive.

It is also illegal to make such a change at this juncture, according to the Federation’s own rulebook.

There is a cut-off date of 30 June by which any regulation changes for the following season must be approved. It is possible to make alterations after that date, but only if said changes are agreed unanimously by all teams. And given that Mercedes - which sits on the much-maligned F1 Strategy Group - is hardly likely to give its support to the concept, forcing through a rule change would be a violation of the regulations. 

The politics of the F1 Strategy Group

The F1 Strategy Group is made up of three voting blocs: selected teams, the FIA, and FOM, with each bloc allocated six votes. At present three of the team members are Mercedes-powered (Mercedes, Williams, and McLaren), although Lotus - who will drop out of the group in 2015, replaced by Merc-powered Force India - have a vested interest in protecting the Mercedes engine, which they will be using next season. McLaren’s move to Honda power for 2015 means they are unlikely to support Mercedes in blocking the unfreeze, but three of the teams with a place on the group will align themselves with Brixworth unless the commercial rights holder can convince them it is in their best interests to support his wishes.

It is on the World Motor Sport Council that further opposition will be found, with Force India team principal Vijay Mallya a vocal member of that body determined to protect one of the few advantages his small-but-mighty team possesses.

But whether or not the concept makes it to the WMSC depends on the idea getting unanimous approval at the next meeting of the F1 Commission, a body which contains representatives from all teams and where unanimity must be found if rules are to be changed so late in the day. That body next sits in a month’s time, at which point we will know whether or not the Mercedes-powered teams and FIA have been convinced by the commercial rights holder that starting yet another financial arms race is in the long-term interests of the sport.

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?

Take our 5 minute survey.

- The Motorsport.com Team

Read and post comments

Read also :

Share Or Save This Story

Copy link

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on WhatsApp

Share on Linkedin

Share on Pinterest

Share on Viber

Previous article Mercedes bosses recognise part Ross Brawn played in their championship success

Next article Mercedes team celebrates constructor's title at Brackley and Brixworth

Top Comments

There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?

View More & Comment

More from

Kate Walker



How local knowledge and data are keys to F1 growth in Asia

Formula 1

Formula 1 Jun 18, 2018

How local knowledge and data are keys to F1 growth in Asia



Insight: How race promoters benefit from F1’s marketing push

Formula 1

Formula 1 Apr 12, 2018

Insight: How race promoters benefit from F1’s marketing push



Analysis: Assessing Formula 1's financial prospects

Formula 1

Formula 1 Dec 10, 2017

Analysis: Assessing Formula 1's financial prospects

More from

Toto Wolff



Toto Wolff explains the emotional Mercedes factory email leaked online

Formula 1

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

9 d

Toto Wolff explains the emotional Mercedes factory email leaked online



Why Toto Wolff sees Ferrari clash as "déjà vu" – and why escalation may be necessary

Formula 1

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

10 d

Why Toto Wolff sees Ferrari clash as "déjà vu" – and why escalation may be necessary



Toto Wolff reveals he is actively vetting “two or three people” to replace him at Mercedes

Formula 1

Formula 1

United States GP

22 d

Toto Wolff reveals he is actively vetting “two or three people” to replace him at Mercedes

More from

Ferrari



The surprising convergence behind F1's increasingly competitive 2026 season

Formula 1

The surprising convergence behind F1's increasingly competitive 2026 season



Max Verstappen on Ferrari clashes: "I would never sign two number-one drivers"

Formula 1

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

5 d

Max Verstappen on Ferrari clashes: "I would never sign two number-one drivers"



Why Ferrari must act now after its own 'Papaya Rules' moment

Formula 1

Mexican GP

Why Ferrari must act now after its own 'Papaya Rules' moment

Latest news



The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point



Fernando Alonso to return to Dakar Rally with Aston Martin in 2027

Dakar

DAKR Dakar 1 h

Fernando Alonso to return to Dakar Rally with Aston Martin in 2027



Hendrick Motorsports announces crew chief change for William Byron and Alex Bowman

NASCAR Cup

NAS NASCAR Cup 15 h

Hendrick Motorsports announces crew chief change for William Byron and Alex Bowman



IndyCar 2026 season review: Meyer Shank Racing

IndyCar

Indy IndyCar 15 h

IndyCar 2026 season review: Meyer Shank Racing

Feature

Discover prime content



The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point

Formula 1

Sao Paulo GP

By Jake Boxall-Legge

The last time two Brazilians raced at home in F1 - and the battle over a point



What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?

Formula 1

Las Vegas GP

By Stuart Codling

What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Colton Herta?



With rallying back in the spotlight, it could probably teach F1 a thing or two

Formula 1

By Maurice Hamilton

With rallying back in the spotlight, it could probably teach F1 a thing or two



How seizing every chance – and making it happen – keeps Pierre Gasly’s fire burning

Formula 1

By Jake Boxall-Legge

How seizing every chance – and making it happen – keeps Pierre Gasly’s fire burning

Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.

From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.

You have 2 options:

Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here

Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page

Manage Alerts

Subscribe