Opinion
Formula 1 Mexican GP
Should McLaren have removed Norris' 'repercussions' after F1 US GP clash?
McLaren's treatment of its F1 title-contending drivers is now equal again after Oscar Piastri collided with Lando Norris during the US Grand Prix sprint
Motorsport Staff
Edited: Oct 24, 2025, 11:15 AM
Copy link
Share on Viber
McLaren was at the forefront of Formula 1 media day ahead of this weekend’s Mexico Grand Prix as Oscar Piastri revealed it had removed the ‘repercussions’ given to Lando Norris.
It came after Norris collided with Piastri on lap one of the Singapore Grand Prix, whilst he was making an overtake on his F1 title rival and team-mate for third at Marina Bay.
McLaren reviewed the incident afterwards and held Norris responsible, feeling he could have avoided the collision.
So, ahead of the following race, the United States Grand Prix, the team said Norris would receive a “minor consequence” for it. That was understood to be giving Piastri priority to choose the order of the two McLarens leaving the pitlane in qualifying.
But that was short lived as last weekend in the Austin sprint race the pair, who are top the two in the drivers’ standings, collided once again.
It came after Piastri attempted a cutback on Norris at Turn 1, lap one but as he did so, he was tagged by Nico Hulkenberg’s Sauber, which was sandwiched between the Australian and Fernando Alonso’s Aston Martin at the apex.
Hulkenberg thus knocked Piastri into Norris, causing both McLaren drivers to retire. Piastri took a “degree of responsibility” and so the championship leader then added that “the consequences on Lando’s side have been removed”.
This comes amid what is now a three-way championship battle as Piastri leads Norris by 14 points with five rounds remaining, while third is the in-form Max Verstappen who is 40 off top.
So, with all of this in mind, our writers give their thoughts on the matter.
Jake Boxall-Legge: No 'repercussions' side-track is good news - now let's enjoy the show
Lando Norris, McLaren, Oscar Piastri, McLaren, Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing
Photo by: Rudy Carezzevoli / Getty Images
For those hoping for a no-holds-barred title scrap between our trio of protagonists in Piastri, Norris and Verstappen, the removal of McLaren's 'repercussions' is good news. Piastri accepted "a degree of responsibility" for his Austin move so, with both drivers having been in the dock, McLaren chose to wipe the slate clean.
McLaren has now cottoned onto the idea that Verstappen is a very real presence in this title fight. Thus, it makes no sense to tie one arm behind its back, even if those ‘repercussions’ were minor.
Like George Costanza's meta-reference to Seinfeld's TV series-within-a-TV series "Jerry", it 'was a show about nothing'. It's good for everyone that all three drivers are effectively playing on level pegging - and hopefully they give us a title battle for the ages. History will likely not remember the context if it indeed does turn out to be a thriller, although the pressure is overwhelmingly on McLaren to ensure that its approach to managing its two drivers was justified.
Now, let's enjoy what we have in front of us. When F1 inevitably unfurls another season characterised by single-driver dominance, which it will, we won't want to regret not living in the moment of 2025's three-way tussle.
Stuart Codling: “He’s not the world champion, he’s a very naughty boy”
Lando Norris, McLaren, Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing
Photo by: Sam Bloxham / LAT Images via Getty Images
It’s pleasing to see that the denouement of the world championship may not play out like that scene in Monty Python’s Life of Brian, and I don’t mean the bit where they all have a singalong while being crucified.
Now that both Norris and Piastri know what will happen when they punch holes in the ‘papaya rules’, the onus is on them to play nicely. Wiping the slate now clean - it was understood the ‘repercussions’ against Norris were due to be in force for more than one race – is a proportionate righting of the wrong at Turn 1 in Austin.
There were those - including McLaren’s PR machine - who wanted to cast the incident as Hulkenberg’s fault. Whereas anyone with a functional grasp of the dynamics of motor racing will grasp that the karting-style cutback Piastri attempted might have worked at most other circuits (and indeed might have worked at Circuit of the Americas at any other time than lap one), but was doomed to end in contact at that point.
If we were to express culpability for the accident in terms of percentages, Piastri’s would be proportionately greater than Hulkenberg’s, Alonso’s, and Norris’. Tempting as it may be to cast Norris as an entirely innocent party, he was where he was because he was trying to compensate for a poor start.
The fact is that racing drivers are like children. Given any instruction or set of rules they will instinctively test the boundaries – not necessarily of the rules themselves but of the willingness of the grown-ups to enforce them.
Spare the rod, spoil the child. McLaren’s leaders have shown due willingness to use the stick. It’s the drivers’ fault if it has to come out again.
Oleg Karpov: McLaren must stop meddling in the F1 drivers’ fight
Lando Norris, McLaren, Oscar Piastri, McLaren
Photo by: Andy Hone/ LAT Images via Getty Images
Overcomplicated. Unnecessary. And, quite frankly, even a bit damaging for F1. McLaren bosses insist they allow their drivers to race, yet when every move is analysed frame-by-frame by your own team, it's hard to race with a clear mind. Both Norris and Piastri are mentally robust enough to deal with the pressure - otherwise you don't reach the point of being in contention for the biggest prize in the racing world - but I wonder if that supervision is playing on their minds every time they get in their cars now.
What happened in Monza was borderline. What happened after Singapore was very hard to understand, as Norris was told off for doing what a title contender is supposed to do. What followed after Austin was either ridiculous or a sign that common sense had finally prevailed.
Maybe McLaren didn't act on Piastri's actions at the start of last Saturday's sprint, but simply admitted it was time to drop that approach altogether - because when Verstappen is closing in with a sword, there's no need to remind your drivers not to crash. One DNF for either of them would let the Dutchman get dangerously close – and he doesn't need a velvet-textured invitation card to come to the party. He'll punish every mistake.
Perhaps everyone at McLaren now understands that holding back its own drivers can be more damaging than letting them race as they know how, because that's what they've been doing their whole lives. Having a bit of trust in your employees doesn't hurt any organisation.
However, it could be just another twist in McLaren's pursuit of a "fair" fight for the championship, which was unachievable in the first place and has already become impossible after Norris' DNF at Zandvoort.
This needs to stop - also for the sake of F1 fans who want to see great drivers battle for a great prize without being held accountable for every misstep.
Photos from Mexican GP - Thursday
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Mexican GP - Thursday, in photos
Formula 1
52
Read Also:
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?
Take our 5 minute survey.
- The Motorsport.com Team
Read and post comments
Read also :
Share Or Save This Story
Copy link
Share on Viber
Previous article Charles Leclerc will be “very surprised” if Max Verstappen wins 2025 F1 title
Next article Lando Norris laughs off Red Bull's attempted sabotage at F1 US GP
Top Comments
There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?
View More & Comment
More from
Motorsport Staff
Five things to look out for at F1 Brazil GP
Formula 1
Formula 1
Sao Paulo GP
10 d
Five things to look out for at F1 Brazil GP
Harvick: NASCAR may penalize Hocevar for 'dirtiest of dirty tricks'
NASCAR Cup
NASCAR Cup
Martinsville II
12 d
Harvick: NASCAR may penalize Hocevar for 'dirtiest of dirty tricks'
Denny Hamlin proud of season despite another likely missed title
NASCAR Cup
NASCAR Cup
Martinsville II
16 d
Denny Hamlin proud of season despite another likely missed title
More from
Lando Norris
McLaren to upgrade MCL40 car at its bogey F1 track Las Vegas
Formula 1
Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
1 d
McLaren to upgrade MCL40 car at its bogey F1 track Las Vegas
F1 driver contracts: How long is each driver tied down for?
Formula 1
Formula 1 2 d
F1 driver contracts: How long is each driver tied down for?
More from
McLaren
What's behind Oscar Piastri's split with Mark Webber – and what it means for his F1 career
Formula 1
Formula 1
Sao Paulo GP
5 d
What's behind Oscar Piastri's split with Mark Webber – and what it means for his F1 career
Latest news
You Ask The Questions: Jack Miller
MotoGP
Qatar GP
You Ask The Questions: Jack Miller
Why the anticlimactic WEC title showdown was the worst-case scenario
WEC
WEC WEC
Monza
3 h
Why the anticlimactic WEC title showdown was the worst-case scenario
How Istanbul is revamping its F1 circuit to clinch long-term future
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Turkish GP
5 h
How Istanbul is revamping its F1 circuit to clinch long-term future
Feature
Discover prime content
Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
You have 2 options:
- Become a subscriber.
- Disable your adblocker.
Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here
Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page
Manage Alerts
Subscribe