Formula 1
F1 mid-season match up - Part 2: Williams vs Red Bull
Yesterday we launched our mid season assessment of teams and drivers so far.
Edited: Aug 13, 2015, 9:30 AM
Copy link
Share on Viber

Motorsport Blog
Motorsport Blog
Yesterday we launched our mid season assessment of teams and drivers so far. We’ve chosen to do it in match-ups between pairs of comparable teams, with our own JA on F1 Ratings for Drivers and teams.
Here we look at the performances of the third and fourth placed teams.
Williams vs Red Bull: Overview
Williams holds third place in the Constructors' table with 151 points, ahead of Red Bull on 96pts, but the four time champions closed up by 33pts at the last round. So what will the run it look like for both teams?
Williams ended the 2014 season as a serious thorn in the side of Mercedes, but over the winter Ferrari’s significant engine upgrade pushed it ahead of the Grove-based squad as the second best team. So far in 2015, Williams has been able to threaten the podium occasionally and currently sits third in the championship, but only goes well on fast tracks that suit the car and it has been poor again at slow-speed circuits and in the wet.
Red Bull has been plagued by reliability issues with its Renault power units all season and the public fallout between the two partners has been one of the talking points of the season. The four-time constructors’ champions were also embarrassed by the superior chassis produced by their junior team Toro Rosso in the early rounds. But its drivers have been scoring points consistently to reside a solid fourth in the championship standings at the half way mark.
Drivers:

Valtteri Bottas’ season got off to a bad start when he injured his back during qualifying for the Australian Grand Prix and had to miss the race. He was back in the points in the next two races before spirited fighting drives with Sebastien Vettel in Bahrain and Kimi Raikkonen in Spain meant he collected a pair of fourth places, but crucially held a faster Ferrari at bay each time. He bounced back from a poor Monaco Grand prix, exacerbated by Williams’ troubles on slow-speed tracks, with a great race to steal a podium from Raikkonen in Canada (helped by his countryman’s spin) and more points in Austria and at Silverstone. But Bottas has not blown away teammate Felipe Massa as many had expected he would given his form in 2014, and he was unable to pass him in the early phase of the British Grand Prix before Williams interfered with team orders. He has admitted that rumours about a move to replace Raikkonen at Ferrari next season haven’t helped and he’ll be hoping bounce back strongly after the summer break.
Massa has continued his late-2014 form and has gathered points with great consistency – which means he has almost double the amount he did at this stage last year. A run of scores in the first five races was only ended with Williams’ poor showing at Monaco and the other time he has failed to score was at the team’s similarly weak performance in Hungary – although he didn’t help matters by lining up incorrectly on the grid and earning a penalty. Massa’s work to hold off the faster Ferrari of Vettel to score a podium in Austria is the highlight of his season so far and his lightning start to seize the lead and keep Hamilton temporarily at bay at Silverstone also stands out. The Brazilian heads Bottas 6-4 in qualifying, which demonstrates he still has the speed to compete with his younger teammate.

Red Bull’s engine woes means that Daniel Ricciardo has been unable to pull off any of the opportunist victories that he earned in 2014 and the Australian has been forced to do battle with the lower end of the points scorers. He has stepped up well to being the senior driver in the Red Bull team and scored a battle-scarred podium at the Hungaroring to head into the summer break on a high. Ricciardo demonstrated his speed with the fastest lap at the Monaco Grand Prix where he also showed his team loyalty by handing Daniil Kvyat fourth place back just before the line.
Kvyat has been under intense observation following Red Bull’s decision to promote him to the senior team after just one year at Toro Rosso. He got off to a poor start by breaking the teams only front wing early on in winter testing – leaving him circulating without a wing for much of the day – and his engine failed on the way to the grid in Australia. He scored a few points in Malaysia, Bahrain and Spain but then drove a sparkling race to fourth place at Monaco. Kvyat struggled, along with Red Bull, at the power tracks of Canada, Austria and Silverstone but he entered the summer break fresh off the back of maiden podium at Hungary as he kept a cool head while many other more experienced drivers did not. Although Ricciardo has a better qualifying record, Kvyat has the better finishing score at 5-4.
JA on F1 Verdict
Bottas - 7/10
Massa - 6.5/10
Ricciardo - 6.5/10
Kvyat - 6/10
Prospects for the rest of the season:
Bottas needs to recover his 2014 pace more frequently if he is to bother the Ferrari pair for the podium more regularly and will want the uncertainty over his future sorted before too long. He has the speed to beat his teammate in the race, but needs to step up in qualifying.

Massa will want to carry on his consistent points scoring and hope to pick up the pieces if the front running teams hit trouble. If he continues his good form, Williams will be unlikely to drop him for next year.
Ricciardo will want to emerge from the power dependent circuits that make up the next few races with as many points as possible and hope any engine penalties don’t leave him too far down the order. Renault has a significant upgrade planned for Sochi so the Australian will be hoping to be back at the sharp end before the end of the season.
Kvyat needs to build on his maiden podium throughout the second half of the year and show the speed his displayed at Toro Rosso more regularly. A quicker car (and engine) will help that but he will want to be more consistent.

Teams:
Much like in 2014, Williams has excelled on fast, power dependent tracks like the Red Bull Ring and Silverstone, but it have struggled around slow-speed circuits in Monaco and Hungary. When the rain came at Silverstone its drivers slid down the order and this demonstrated the chassis’ fundamental weakness: poor rear-end downforce levels. The team show indecisiveness at Silverstone when telling Bottas not to attack Massa, only to go back on that call a few laps later and its strategy calls have generally been too much on the conservative side to exploit opportunities.
Red Bull has made its feelings about Renault’s engine perfectly clear, but the team’s chassis was also outshone by Toro Rosso in the early part of the year as it lost advantages in underfoot aero and had problems with the front wing. Once it got those issues ironed out the chassis is probably second best after Mercedes, but, much like last year, the power unit is holding the team back.
JA on F1 Verdict
Williams - 7/10
Red Bull - 6.5/10
Prospects for the rest of the season:
Williams really need to work on improving its rear downforce levels or the squad will really struggle at tracks like Singapore. The team also needs to be more aggressive with its strategy calls and be pro-active rather than reactive if its drivers are going to score the podium finishes that were a staple of last year and keep Red Bull at arm's length.

Red Bull will be hoping Renault’s Sochi upgrade hits its targets if the team want to fight for wins at the end of the season. The chassis is good so if the power problem is cured it might just be able to overhaul Williams for third place in the constructor’s championship.
Why is there a mid-season break? Here's our background explanation.
Do you agree with our ratings? Leave your own, together with your comments in the section below
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motorsport.com?
Take our 5 minute survey.
- The Motorsport.com Team
Read and post comments
Read also :
Share Or Save This Story
Copy link
Share on Viber
Previous article Team bosses must do more to promote F1, says Lotus
Next article F1 engine battle could still turn, says Mercedes
Top Comments
There are no comments at the moment. Would you like to write one?
View More & Comment

More from
Daniel Ricciardo

“I was getting beat up” – How Daniel Ricciardo burned out on ‘humiliating’ F1 return
Formula 1
Formula 1 7 d
“I was getting beat up” – How Daniel Ricciardo burned out on ‘humiliating’ F1 return

Why Daniel Ricciardo is staying away from the F1 paddock
Formula 1
Formula 1 17 d
Why Daniel Ricciardo is staying away from the F1 paddock

Why Daniel Ricciardo would consider a comeback at Le Mans
WEC
WEC 22 d
Why Daniel Ricciardo would consider a comeback at Le Mans

More from
McLaren

How McLaren tried to mitigate its Las Vegas F1 top speed deficit
Formula 1
Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
1 h
How McLaren tried to mitigate its Las Vegas F1 top speed deficit

Lando Norris frustrated by McLaren's "shocking" top speed at Las Vegas GP qualifying
Formula 1
Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
4 h
Lando Norris frustrated by McLaren's "shocking" top speed at Las Vegas GP qualifying

Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s
Formula 1
Top 10 F1 cars of the 1980s
Latest news

MotoGP to move race start time in 2027, avoid F1 clashes
MotoGP
MGP MotoGP 52 min
MotoGP to move race start time in 2027, avoid F1 clashes

MotoGP Portuguese Grand Prix: Marco Bezzecchi on pole, Marc Marquez second
MotoGP
MGP MotoGP
Portuguese GP
1 h
MotoGP Portuguese Grand Prix: Marco Bezzecchi on pole, Marc Marquez second

How McLaren tried to mitigate its Las Vegas F1 top speed deficit
Formula 1
F1 Formula 1
Las Vegas GP
1 h
How McLaren tried to mitigate its Las Vegas F1 top speed deficit
Feature
Discover prime content
Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
You have 2 options:
- Become a subscriber.
- Disable your adblocker.
Subscribe now Already subscribed? Sign in here
Already disabled your adblocker?
Reload page
Manage Alerts
Subscribe




