F1 fans back Carlos Sainz's TV pundit steward suggestion as Karun Chandhok responds
Formula 1 fans have largely backed Carlos Sainz's call for expert TV analysts like Karun Chandhok, Anthony Davidson and Jolyon Palmer to join the stewarding panel
Carlos Sainz, Williams
Photo by: Dom Gibbons / LAT Images via Getty Images
Formula 1 fans have shared their support for Carlos Sainz's suggestion of using TV pundits and former F1 drivers Karun Chandhok, Anthony Davidson and Jolyon Palmer as stewards.
The Spaniard praised the analysis of recent incidents from the three former drivers while discussing the application of the F1 driving guidelines. "I've seen some analysis done of quite a lot of the incidents, and I think there was some of them Karun Chandhok, in some of them Jolyon Palmer, some of them Anthony Davidson," he said.
"Every time I see this analysis that they do and the verdict that they give from racing drivers that have been recently racing, I think they do a very good analysis and they put the blame correctly most of the time on who actually has the blame, or if it's actually just a racing incident."
He added: "I really feel like they understood what happened in that incident and the judgement that they take. And this doesn't mean that the stewards don't do a good job, it just means what I see after the race from these people is actually a very high level. I think without guidelines they would be able to judge each decision correctly and there wouldn't be a bias or anything like that."
Many fans backed Sainz's suggestion in a Reddit discussion. "Then we'd also get an episode/podcast after the race with an explanation and breakdown of how and why each decision was made. That would be fantastic," one fan wrote, while another added: "I would feel very comfortable having Ant, Karun and Jolyon as FIA stewards. Easily."
"I love the Sky Pad segments and JP’s analysis on F1 TV. The way they break it down is always illuminating for the lay person imo [sic]," someone else wrote, and another responded: "I would, too. But I'd be very sad to miss Jolyon 'I'll have a go' Palmer on the F1 TV feed."
"Karun clearly has the most knowledge on the Sky Sports crew, and probably on the stewarding panel as well," shared another fan.
Others pointed to the difficulties which the current stewards face. "I like Karun and Jolyon's analysis a lot of the time. That said, they're not under the same level of pressure when they're breaking something down on television. Context matters, much like when watching an event on television and the refs blow calls. I understand it's not going to be cool to defend the stewards. I recommend everyone serve as some form of referee in their lives--it's not easy," one argued.
Chandhok also responded to the proposed idea. "Ha! Thanks @Carlossainz55
…. Would be good to work with the drivers and stewards for the betterment of the sport but not ready to give up the day job yet," he wrote on X.
Photos from Qatar GP - Practice
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Qatar GP - Friday, in photos
Share Or Save This Story
Martin Brundle opens up on the brutal moment he learned he had lost his F1 seat
Mark Webber’s Oscar Piastri role change was inevitable, says David Coulthard
Jenson Button reunites with Brawn GP as all three 2009 chassis come together at Goodwood
Karun Chandhok impressed by Kimi Antonelli: "Had the upper hand" over George Russell all weekend
Karun Chandhok reveals Helmut Marko moment that explains Red Bull’s ruthless success
Chandhok: Why charming F1 boss Williams will be dearly missed
Martin Brundle labels Williams’s 2026 F1 start “very concerning” after early setbacks
F1’s 2026 reset spreads field out to its widest since 2017
F1 2026 team-mate battles: Are 'slower' drivers suddenly more competitive?
WEC Imola: Toyota denies Ferrari home win in season opener
Has Ducati stagnated or have its MotoGP rivals caught up?
Nurburgring 24h Qualifiers: Scherer-Audi wins as Max Verstappen's show unrewarded
F1 bosses explain long-term push to fill 24-race calendar
Why this quintessential late-1970s F1 car stands out in the history of the Tyrrell team
The political shift that will determine F1's next engine formula
Is it now or never for Russell in hunt for F1 title?
The top 11 lost F1 victories after the flag
Subscribe and access Motorsport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
Top Comments