Analysis: Why engines are an easy scapegoat for F1 woes

The current V6 hybrid turbo engines have been blamed for a lot of the problems Formula 1 is having. But that's just a very simplistic view, as Kate Walker explains.

Analysis: Why engines are an easy scapegoat for F1 woes
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 W06 leads at the start of the race
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 Team and Nico Rosberg, Mercedes AMG F1 Team 06
The 2015 Renault Energy F1 engine
Bernie Ecclestone
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 Team and Nico Rosberg, Mercedes AMG F1 Team 06
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 W06 and Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari SF15-T battle for position
Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director
Maurizio Arrivabene, Ferrari Team Principal with Bernie Ecclestone, and Eddie Jordan, BBC Television Pundit
Daniil Kvyat, Red Bull Racing RB11 retired from the race with a blown engine
Ferrari SF15-T engine cover detail
Mercedes AMG F1 W06 engine cover
The 2015 Renault Energy F1 engine
The FIA Press Conference,): John Booth, Manor F1 Team Team Principal; Eric Boullier, McLaren Racing Director; Rob White, Renault Sport Deputy Managing Director,; Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director; Monisha Kaltenborn, Sauber Te
(L to R): Paddy Lowe, Mercedes AMG F1 Executive Director, with Bernie Ecclestone, of the FOM; and Toto Wolff, Mercedes AMG F1 Shareholder and Executive Director
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 W06
Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF15-T leads team mate Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari SF15-T
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes AMG F1 W06 leads at the start of the race

At its best, Formula 1 is spectacular.

As the 2014 Bahrain Grand Prix proved, wheel-to-wheel battles can and do take place in modern grand prix racing.

Whatever we learned about engine settings in the aftermath of Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg's multi-lap duel around the Sakhir Circuit last year, there was no doubt in the minds of those present that they were watching our generation's equivalent of the legendary 1979 French Grand Prix battle for second place between Gilles Villeneuve and Rene Arnoux.

It was F1 history in the making.

While the 2015 Bahrain race might not have lived up to those dizzying heights, watching Kimi Raikkonen closing in on a struggling Rosberg was a nail-biting, edge-of-your-seat moment, counting the gains made by the Ferrari driver with every passing sector and screaming at backmarkers to get out of the way and stop ruining the potential for a close finish.

It is races such as these that hook new fans, and make old ones reacquaint their love for Formula 1 all over again.

Ecclestone and V8s

F1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone likes to place the blame for falling spectator numbers squarely at the feet of the current V6 turbo engines. This conveniently overlooks the 30 percent decline over the past five years that includes a four-year period when the sport was powered by the V8s he is so keen to restore.

Speaking to the media over the course of the Bahrain race weekend, Ecclestone hammered the point home day after day.

On Thursday, the commercial rights holder was confident that a return to V8s is what it would take to save the sport, although he neglected to provide any evidence of why such a move would reverse declining interest in F1 from fans and sponsors alike.

"We need to go back to engines whose costs are more reasonable and we need to intervene with maximum urgency," Ecclestone said.

"We'd just need to take the old V8 engines and modify them by increasing displacement to bring power output near 1000bhp. People would return, the show would return, sponsors would return."

By Sunday, having discussed the issue with team bosses understandably keen to stick with their V6 hybrid power units, the 84-year-old was a little more flexible. Remarkably, his comments included an acknowledgement that the current cost of competition was excessive.

Asked whether F1's future might see modified V6s, Ecclestone replied: "Yeah, sure. Absolutely. But at what price? The two things that have to happen are whoever supplies the engines to the teams have to supply the same engines as they currently use.

"If it's going to be the current engine, and upgraded to 1000bhp, then good. They need to supply that to the teams at a price that the teams can afford to pay."

Ecclestone later said that discussions with F1's team principals verged on the pointless, telling the press that: "It's no good talking to these people. They have to be told."

Engine concessions

But senior team personnel – even those representing the sport's engine suppliers – are willing to make concessions to the current formula if that is what is deemed necessary to ensure spectacular racing and reinvigorate interest in the sport.

"The discussion about a 1000bhp engine has been around quite a while," Toto Wolff told Motorsport.com. "And I appreciate very well that it needs to be a spectacular formula, and if that's the way forward then we should continue to work on it.

"All engine manufacturers are pretty clear that the current engine architecture with a hybrid component needs to stay in place. This is the direction we've headed to, and this is at least at the moment the current status between Ferrari, Renault, Honda and Mercedes.

"By 2017 those engines, between all manufacturers, are going to have north of 900bhp. Then it's a question of how do you want to market that? Does it make a big difference between having 950bhp or 1000?

"I think there are pretty easy tools to increase the horsepower, and this is increasing fuel flow. If you want to increase the fuel flow by 10kgs an hour or 20kgs or whatever it is, then you are going to have more than 1000bhp."

Wolff's point is the only one worth making. Since the introduction of the hybrid power units in 2014, Formula 1 has seen a variety of races, from the instant classic of last year's Bahrain round to thrillers from the back of the grid as seen in Germany and Hungary.

There have also been less-than-exciting rounds, such as Sochi last year and the 2015 season opener in Melbourne, but such is motorsport – not every race can be a thriller. You need a few routine races to make the fantastic ones stand out.

Technology not promoted properly

The V6 hybrid power units are a technological marvel, and the fact that F1 cars are as fast or faster than they were with the old V8s – despite using one-third less fuel over the course of the race – is a spectacular achievement.

But how widely was it promoted? Instead, the commercial rights holder pulled a 'Ratner' and rubbished the achievements of the sport that has made him a multi-billionaire.

Who's to say the 2017 technological revolution won't bring more of the same from a man always looking for the political advantage?

Spectacular racing can happen in any category, with any engine formula, and at any budget. If no one is watching, perhaps that is the fault of the barriers to fan access, and not the technology itself.

shares
comments
Vettel named ADAC Formula 4 patron

Previous article

Vettel named ADAC Formula 4 patron

Next article

Horner: "If we had eight engines a season it might help us" - But will rescue plan go through?

Horner: "If we had eight engines a season it might help us" - But will rescue plan go through?
Load comments
What needs to “change” for Red Bull is ending Verstappen’s errors Prime

What needs to “change” for Red Bull is ending Verstappen’s errors

OPINION: Going up against the dominant force of Mercedes and Lewis Hamilton was always going to demand the best from Red Bull and Max Verstappen. But after making a couple more errors during the Portuguese Grand Prix, the Dutch driver showed there's a small gap he still needs to close in the 2021 Formula 1 title fight.

The "subtle" Red Bull upgrades that kept it in the Portugal F1 mix Prime

The "subtle" Red Bull upgrades that kept it in the Portugal F1 mix

Red Bull's Portuguese Grand Prix fortunes were decidedly second best to Mercedes', but the result skews the potential that the team had at Portimao. With a new set of updates, the team looks good going forward into the rest of 2021's spicy F1 competition

Formula 1
May 3, 2021
Portuguese Grand Prix driver ratings Prime

Portuguese Grand Prix driver ratings

The 2021 Portuguese GP will for several drivers go down as a weekend of missed opportunities amid imperfect track conditions that caused struggles with tyre warm-up. But the performances of a select few stood out from the crowd

Formula 1
May 3, 2021
The five key tests Hamilton passed to claim Portugal victory Prime

The five key tests Hamilton passed to claim Portugal victory

Just as he did in 2020, Lewis Hamilton had to come from behind to win the 2021 Portuguese Grand Prix. Only this time there were two rivals he had to pass, among the several challenges he had to overcome, on his way to securing a 97th grand prix victory

Formula 1
May 3, 2021
Imola 1994: Memories from Ayrton Senna’s F1 rivals Prime

Imola 1994: Memories from Ayrton Senna’s F1 rivals

The tragic events of the 1994 San Marino Grand Prix changed Formula 1 forever. Here, 17 of the drivers who took part explain how they coped with the devastating deaths of Roland Ratzenberger and Ayrton Senna.

Formula 1
May 1, 2021
The data that leaves both Red Bull, Mercedes uncertain of supremacy Prime

The data that leaves both Red Bull, Mercedes uncertain of supremacy

Lewis Hamilton topped the crucial FP2 session on Friday as F1 returned to Portugal, but his Mercedes team cannot be sure it has the edge on its Red Bull rivals. As cool temperatures and wind combine with the still-slippery surface to present drivers with quandaries over set-up and tyre warmup, there's still everything to play for come qualifying.

Formula 1
May 1, 2021
How in-form Norris is staking his claim as Britain's next F1 champion Prime

How in-form Norris is staking his claim as Britain's next F1 champion

As a highly-rated Mercedes junior, George Russell is naturally billed as Lewis Hamilton's heir apparent where Britain's next Formula 1 champion is concerned. But he may face competition for that accolade from Lando Norris, fresh from a confidence-boosting run to third at Imola whose rise is being accelerated by his McLaren team’s revival

Formula 1
Apr 29, 2021
The biggest headache F1 faces over its sprint race experiments Prime

The biggest headache F1 faces over its sprint race experiments

The news this week that F1 has green-lit 'sprint qualifying' races that will determine the grid for three grands prix in 2021 was met with a blend of excitement and scepticism. But before those in both camps can be vilified, F1 must first work out what its criteria is for success - and what will justify making them a more permanent fixture

Formula 1
Apr 28, 2021