Analysis: How VW's emissions scandal will impact its F1 future

Could entering F1 be a saving grace for VW following the recent emissions scandal, or will its motorsport programme take a big hit? Kate Walker analyses the possible outcomes of one of the industry's biggest ever scandals.

Analysis: How VW's emissions scandal will impact its F1 future
Jari-Matti Latvala and Miikka Anttila, Volkswagen Polo WRC, Volkswagen Motorsport
Antonio Giovinazzi, Jagonya Ayam with Carlin Dallara F312 - Volkswagen
Winners and 2015 WRC champions Sébastien Ogier and Julien Ingrassia, Volkswagen Polo WRC, Volkswagen Motorsport
VAG Chaiman of the Board Martin Winterkorn watches the end of the race while the last Peugeot 908 on track retires
Andreas Mikkelsen and Ola Floene, Volkswagen Polo WRC, Volkswagen Motorsport
Jari-Matti Latvala and Miikka Anttila, Volkswagen Polo WRC, Volkswagen Motorsport
Winner and 2015 WRC champion Sébastien Ogier, Volkswagen Motorsport
VAG Chaiman of the Board Martin Winterkorn and Dr. Wolfgang Ullrich watch the end of the race while the last Peugeot 908 on track retires
Jost Capito
Julien Ingassia, Volkswagen Motorsport
Andreas Mikkelsen and Ola Floene, Volkswagen Polo WRC, Volkswagen Motorsport
Dr. Martin Winterkorn Head of Volkswagen AG with Timo Scheider, Audi Sport Team Abt Audi A4 DTM
Jost Capito
George Russell, Carlin Dallara F312 Volkswagen
#7 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Marcel Fässler, Andre Lotterer, Benoit Tréluyer
Sébastien Ogier and Julien Ingrassia, Volkswagen Polo WRC, Volkswagen Motorsport
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis

Over the course of the past week, the Volkswagen Automotive Group has found itself dominating the headlines, first with a renewal of the rumours around its potential F1 entry with Audi, and then with the destruction of their public image when it emerged that the company had been deliberately cheating vehicle emissions tests on up to 11 million cars.

While there are many compelling reasons for VAG to expand its motorsports programme to include Formula 1, the emissions revelations have had a heavy cost.

Not only is the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) expected to hit VAG with sizeable fines for its deceit, but consumer confidence in the brand is at an all-time low. Since news of VW's "defeat device" emerged, $44.8 billion has been wiped off the value of the company.

So what does this mean for those F1 rumours bandied about in more profitable times?

Poor timing

From a financial standpoint, the size of the potential fine VW faces should put the kibosh on any plans to enter Formula 1. With a possible $18 billion fine levied by the US government and operating profits of around $14 billion per annum, the German automotive giant will not be in the rudest of fiscal health in the immediate future.

Add to that the rapid depreciation in VW's share value, which dropped 20 percent on Monday alone, and a new F1 programme looks to be both frivolous and prohibitively expensive.

VW have put aside $7.3 billion to cover anticipated fines, and the company has cash reserves of $24 billion - more than enough to pay penalties without going into the red, but with jobs now at stake and the German economy under threat it will be hard for the board to make a convincing argument that its presence in F1 is of vital importance.

Few expect VW's total fines to reach the $18 billion figure that has been bandied about. The Environmental Protection Agency fined BP $5.5 billion for environmental violations under the Clean Waters Act, and industry experts say that it is rare for maximum penalties to be extracted.

In an interview with Business Insider, Michael Steel - an environmental lawyer at Morrison Foerster - said that the EPA's Notice of Violation was traditionally used as a starting point for negotiations.

"The NOV is an invitation to enter into settlement negotiations," Steel said. "I wouldn't be surprised if VW and the EPA have already held preliminary talks on the matter. … The maximum is almost never reached. The EPA will determine an appropriate amount that makes violating the regulation no longer financially worthwhile."

Steel predicts that VW and the EPA will come to an overall settlement of around $1 billion that will also include a civil penalty.

Still, even that figure is more than three times higher than the previous record penalty of $300 million levied by the EPA against Hyundai and Kia after their own emissions violations in 2014. General Motors paid $900 million following their failure to enforce a timely recall of cars with faulty ignitions.

More than 50 class-action lawsuits have already been filed in the United States and Canada, although fewer than 500,000 vehicles are said to be affected in the US.

In Europe, more than 11 million vehicles have been sold by a manufacturer known to have deliberately deceived their customers, and the financial penalties will only escalate. Private individuals in Germany have begun filing claims with the public prosecutor, and the number of claimants is escalating rapidly as more details of the scandal emerge.

There are also concerns that the VAG scandal could impact the German automotive industry as a whole, potentially affecting a key sector of the German economy and up to 775,000 jobs - or two percent of the German workforce.

With consumer confidence in Volkswagen now at an all-time low, it would be particularly tactless timing for the Group to announce that it was launching an F1 programme.

F1's biggest supporter gone

From a corporate standpoint, the resignation of CEO Martin Winterkorn is another reason to bet against VW entering Formula 1. Winterkorn was widely considered to be the greatest supporter of an F1 effort on the VW board, and his departure makes the notion of Volkswagen adding to its existing roster of motorsports commitments less likely.

As VW was one of the manufacturers involved in developing the 2014 F1 power unit regulations, it was widely hoped that the marque would enter the sport when the new hybrid era began. But in 2012, VW AG motorsport director Jost Capito pointed at the WRC programme as the reason behind VW's lack of F1 interest.

"I've got my hands full with the WRC right now and we have to focus on that," Capito said. "This is the very much the main motorsport programme for us and the board is watching it very closely. I think that's what we have to deliver."

Despite Capito pointing to the World Rally Championship as VW's main competitive focus, the marque can also be found competing in Rallycross, Formula 3, and DTM, not to mention the twin LMP1 programmes of Audi and Porsche, and their GT efforts with Bentley and Lamborghini.

Scandal a boost to F1 hopes?

Ironically, there is a chance that the scandal could make an F1 effort more likely, not less.

With VW having suffered a dramatic loss of public confidence as a result of their deliberate rigging of the emissions tests, a concerted effort to develop efficient hybrid racing engines for use in a championship powered by fuel efficiency and energy recovery systems - as F1 now is - would be a public statement of the manufacturer's intent when it comes to cleaning up its act.

It was the TDI cars in VW's range that were designed to game the emissions tests, and to produce an FIA-compliant turbo-powered engine could turn a negative into a positive, particularly if VW are able to achieve the seemingly impossible and develop a competitive power unit on a par with Mercedes.

'Win on Sunday, sell on Monday' may no longer apply as an adage, but if the German manufacturer is able to do better with its F1 turbos than rivals Renault and Honda, there is a great narrative for use in future marketing of their turbo range.

Bizarrely, an F1 programme - however unlikely it may seem - could prove to be the saving grace of VAG's turbo-powered vehicles, even allowing for the fact that Formula 1 is hardly reputed to be the apogee of either corporate ethics or environmental responsibility.

shares
comments
Ecclestone says Lotus Renault deal needs to be sealed by Monday

Previous article

Ecclestone says Lotus Renault deal needs to be sealed by Monday

Next article

Mercedes: Limited running in wet conditions on Day One at Suzuka

Mercedes: Limited running in wet conditions on Day One at Suzuka
Load comments
How Monza only added more questions to F1's sprint race conundrum Prime

How Monza only added more questions to F1's sprint race conundrum

With two sprint races under its belt, Formula 1 must now consider its options for them going forward. While they've helped deliver exciting racing on Sundays, the sprints themselves have been somewhat lacking - creating yet another conundrum for F1 to solve...

Who should Alfa Romeo sign for 2022's F1 season? Prime

Who should Alfa Romeo sign for 2022's F1 season?

OPINION: With Valtteri Bottas already signed up for 2022, all eyes are on the race for the second seat at Alfa Romeo next year. Antonio Giovinazzi is the current incumbent, but faces a tough competition from appealing short and long-term prospects

Formula 1
Sep 15, 2021
The "forced break" that was key to Ricciardo's Monza excellence Prime

The "forced break" that was key to Ricciardo's Monza excellence

OPINION: Daniel Ricciardo has long been considered one of Formula 1's elite drivers. But his struggles at McLaren since switching from Renault for 2021 have been painful to watch at times. Yet he's recovered to banish those memories with a famous Monza win – built on a critically important foundation

Formula 1
Sep 14, 2021
Italian Grand Prix driver ratings Prime

Italian Grand Prix driver ratings

Two drivers produced faultless performances as, for the second year in a row, Monza threw up an unpredictable result that left many to rue what might have been

Formula 1
Sep 13, 2021
Why Ricciardo would have won without Verstappen/Hamilton crash Prime

Why Ricciardo would have won without Verstappen/Hamilton crash

The clash between Max Verstappen and Lewis Hamilton was the major flashpoint the 2021 Italian Grand Prix will be remembered for. Yet by this point, race leader Daniel Ricciardo had already done the hard work that would put him in position to end his and McLaren's lengthy win droughts, on a memorable afternoon in Monza

Formula 1
Sep 13, 2021
Why Italian GP success is on for McLaren even if Verstappen dominates Prime

Why Italian GP success is on for McLaren even if Verstappen dominates

For the second time in 2021, McLaren will line up for the start of a grand prix from the first row. It knows it has the chance of "glory" if things go well for Daniel Ricciardo and Lando Norris at the start of the 2021 Italian Grand Prix, but even if they just maintain their grid positions, signs from the rest of the Monza weekend suggest success is very possible for Formula 1's other orange army

Formula 1
Sep 12, 2021
How Formula 1 has made itself unattractive to new teams Prime

How Formula 1 has made itself unattractive to new teams

OPINION: The Formula 1 cost cap has been billed as a saviour to several teams and helped to guarantee their viability for investors. But there already exists another mechanism that effectively had the same purpose, and serves as a strong deterrent for those with the means to go it alone in setting up a new team

Formula 1
Sep 10, 2021
How Schumacher's first year marked him out as F1's king in-waiting Prime

How Schumacher's first year marked him out as F1's king in-waiting

After his sparkling F1 debut with Jordan at Spa, Michael Schumacher quickly leapt to Benetton for the 1991 Italian Grand Prix. This move paved the way for the German to win his first grand prix one year later and laid the foundations for his ascent to become a title contender by 1994.

Formula 1
Sep 10, 2021